Transcript of ICANN GNSO Public Forum on New gTLD Policy
26 March 2007 - Lisbon
Exchange Between NCUC Chairman Milton Mueller and GNSO Chairman Bruce Tonkin (who is also nominated to ICANN Board)
Full transcript here.
Effexor online without prescription, >>MILTON MUELLER: I love you, Bruce. The answer to bureaucracy is more bureaucracy.
[ Laughter ]
>>MILTON MUELLER: It's just wonderful to watch this process gathering steam. Effexor, But I have a lot of comments about this process, as you might know. But I want to start with a very simple question. Just it's a very simple question, and I want to see how you -- not just you, Bruce, but anybody who participated in the sewing together of this Frankenstein monster would answer it, effexor online without prescription.
And the question is, buy effexor once daily, is it possible for anybody to create a controversial proposal and get it approved under this process.
>>KURT PRITZ: Yes. Order cheap effexor, So the answer is yes. I think that it's probably a long and costly process. Effexor online without prescription, I think it has to be defined for the applicant up front. But also, that we need to -- There's lots of noncontroversial strings and applications out there, order discount effexor online.
>>MILTON MUELLER: Let me just understand first how it would happen.
So if I propose dot abortion and the Catholic church weighs in against me, Buy effexor canada, do you tell the Catholic church to take a flying leap or what.
>>BRUCE TONKIN: Well, you work it through the process.
And what's the basis for objecting to that, effexor online without prescription. Is it on the basis -- Is there a law against abortion, buy effexor cheap. There is in some places. I don't think it would necessarily be the Catholic church that would be able to do it on the basis of being a religious organization. Order effexor, >>MILTON MUELLER: Anything that is controversial, there is going to be a law against it somewhere. Effexor online without prescription, Is that not right.
>>BRUCE TONKIN: Well, there's two elements to it, order effexor online.
Maybe I'll answer your first question because I don't want to go down -- I can see myself getting into trouble on that particular topic.
But -- or the particular example, Purchase effexor overnight delivery, I should say.
But let me put it another way.
Controversial strings have already got into the root, effexor online without prescription. Every TLD that -- in fact, many of the TLDs in the second round had significant objection, no rx effexor, and some of those have got through, so I think the answer to -- I'm using controversial in the sense that there are objections to it, Cheap effexor pill, yes, it can get through. If you are going to choose particular words, I don't know the outcome because -- but as a category, effexor for sale, is it possible for something controversial to get through. Yes. Cheapest effexor prices, In fact, it already has. Effexor online without prescription, And I'm not saying --
>>MILTON MUELLER: Wait, wait. They weren't using this proposal. They were not using this proposal, online pharmacy effexor. So that doesn't really answer the question.
I'm asking under this proposal, Find effexor no prescription required, which seems to be inviting anybody in the world to object to something that they think is against their values somehow, their legal --
>>BRUCE TONKIN: But there's a fairly -- there's a bar to do that, though. That's the difference, effexor online without prescription.
>>MILTON MUELLER: So what is the bar, cheapest generic effexor.
>>BRUCE TONKIN: Well, the bar, Discount effexor online, taking the example of -- let's take the bank example. What I'm saying is the objector to that -- let's say someone applies for dot bank. The objector is that is not just a bank objects. Effexor online without prescription, They would have to show they have the support of the banking community to object. So in other words, cheap effexor tablet, we're flipping it around to a degree. We're not requiring them --
>>MILTON MUELLER: In that case, Buy discount effexor online, you're talking not so much about semantic controversiality, you are talking about a proper matchup of the applicant and the idea represented, which at least has something to say for it.
But it seems to me that you have opened the door wide to purely semantic or sensorial types of objections here, buy effexor pills, with your discussions of morality and public order and your invitation for so-called legitimate groups to express objection basically on just value conflicts.
>>BRUCE TONKIN: But what we are saying there is there have to be widely accepted values, Canada effexor, if you like, internationally.
So it's not just a --
>>MILTON MUELLER: So it's the clash of civilizations, is it, effexor online without prescription.
>>BRUCE TONKIN: It could be, but the particular one that you -- the particular example you have suggested, cheapest effexor price, abortion is probably something that you'd -- that would be something that would need to go through the process and we would see what comes out of it.
But the question you are asking is is it an internationally accepted legal norm not to have abortion. Effexor internet, I don't actually know the answer to that question. But if it was, then yes, I think that probably is basis for objection on that particular word, effexor in uk. Effexor online without prescription, >>MILTON MUELLER: And I think that's tragic, that you are basically saying -- you are creating a political process of censorship.
You're sort of abandoning 300 years of liberal ideology about freedom of expression and saying that we are going to decide what is allowed to be uttered at the top level based on an alleged universality that doesn't exist. And I would just remind you that one of the ways that we ended several centuries of religious warfare was not by deciding which religion was right; it was by the principle of tolerance, Effexor order, which allowed all the religions to exist and separated state power from expression and conscious and belief. And that's, I'd suggest, a direction we have to go, cheap effexor in canada. I can go and registering FUCK. See if it goes up there, effexor online without prescription. In the second level in a number of domains. Low cost effexor, >>BRUCE TONKIN: Yes.
>>MILTON MUELLER: And the world didn't fall apart. And I can register Jihad, and I can register -- I would invite you all to look at what's under God.com or Jesus.com, effexor australia. Effexor online without prescription, We didn't have massive global political fights about who got those domains. There's not that much difference. There are some differences, Lowest price effexor, but there's not that much differences between the top level and the second level unless you make them into issues. You can create a political conflict and a need for political conflict if you try. I mean --
>>BRUCE TONKIN: Let me be clear.
If you insert that word that you've just suggested, I'm certain you'll have political conflict, effexor online without prescription.
>>MILTON MUELLER: At the top level, canadian pharmacy effexor. And I'm suggesting.
>>BRUCE TONKIN: At ICANN. Cheap effexor pharmacy, You absolutely will. Effexor online without prescription, I think there are a number of governments that would certainly find that -- yeah, there would be political conflict. I'll leave it at that.
>>MILTON MUELLER: Well, my mother would not approve, cheap effexor in usa. But that's neither here nor there.
The point is, Effexor drug, you are a technical coordinator of the top-level domain name system. You're not an arbiter of global speech norms, effexor online without prescription.
>>BRUCE TONKIN: Yeah. The other way I'd answer that, Milton, effexor online stores, and this is just speaking personally, I think the difference at the moment, Effexor in us, as opposed to where it might end up, but the difference at the moment is, there's a relatively few names at the top level. And if I just add one single name, effexor canada, I don't add any other names, and I add the name you've suggested, Cheap effexor in uk, I think that would be controversial.
If you add that name at the second level to dot com, it is one name amongst 40 million, and that particular word is probably spelled already in a thousand different ways already, buy effexor on internet. Effexor online without prescription, So adding another way is a sort of drop in the ocean.
So I think that would be why I think there would be political issues right now, because we are creating -- we have artificial scarcity there, Purchase effexor online, and you add the word at that level, it kind of stands out. That's just a personal view.
>>MILTON MUELLER: Just one other factual point, effexor overnight shipping. That is, when you look at the proposed grounds for an objection to a string, all but the second one there has perhaps something to say for it. And you've been invoking this international treaty, which is basically a trademark treaty, effexor online without prescription. And the thing about trademark is that it's not a standard for determining whether you get to utter a word or whether it gets to be published. It is a grounds for determining exclusivity between two applicants, so that if one applicant's use of the term encroaches on another's, then you have some basis for saying, you get it and you don't.
But you do not have that as a basis -- there's no legal grounds, there are no universally accepted legal norms for saying you can't have that word at all. Nobody can have it.
And so you cannot invoke this existing body of international law to justify what you're doing here.
....
Similar posts: Epogen online without prescription. Estrace online without prescription. Estrace vaginal cream online without prescription. Extenze online without prescription. Fatblast online without prescription. Female rx plus liquid online without prescription. Female rx plus oil online without prescription. Flovent online without prescription. Flucort cream online without prescription. Fluticasone ointment online without prescription.
Trackbacks from: Effexor online without prescription. Glyburide without prescription. Buy modalert without prescription. Malegra fxt (sildenafil + fluoxetine) without a prescription. Ophthacare eye drops online without prescription. Buy zero nicotine without prescription. Benzac ac online without prescription. Buy arimidex without prescription. Hydrochlorothiazide without prescription. Cialis jelly without prescription.












